2006. Photo by John Pappas.
Visiting GTMO: Hiding in Plain Sight
With headlines sourced from Washington to Hong Kong,
what happens at the Naval Station at Guantanamo Bay must be very
"Uncertainty Hangs over Guantanamo," Washington Post,
"At Guantanamo, Treatment May Be Nice Word for Torture," Daily Star,
Lebanon, April 2006
"Security Services Leaked to Guantanamo 'Injustice'," Guardian, UK,
"British Guantanamo Detainee Alleged Abuse," CRI, China, February
Headlines such as these have filled Internet search engine
databases. There as so many that 56 pages of Google searching only goes back
three months. Interestingly, news is not what this editor found on a trip
there in January.
So why write anything? That was my thought until a certain
Marine Lieutenant Colonel or two suggested that I put the story to rest, by
putting it online, so here we are, nine and a half weeks later.
The command staff of the Joint
Task Force - Guantanamo Bay, the people who oversee the detainee camps and
the press visits among other things, have a very organized arrangement for
press visits. It appeared that the JTF staff sincerely want to receive the
press. While the tasks of taking reporters to and fro throughout the base,
eating, conversing, recreating with them - while remaining gracious and
accommodating may seem unchallenging, it really can't be very easy. Considering
the many different angles and expectations that journalists from all over
the globe arrive with, just getting the mission accomplished is a feat in
For instance, Corps Stories mission was to
determine the well-being of the Marines stationed on GTMO. The first
misconception realized was that Marines, by and large, don't handle
detainees. There are a few Marines who do, and what they do is extremely
important, as they deliver and inform detainees of the Administrative Review
Board and its results. It is the work of thousands of Navy Master-of-Arms
which insures the well-being of detainees on a daily basis.
Marines man the fence between the Naval base and the rest of
the country of Cuba (remember GTMO is not on American soil, in any form). Good
ground relations with the Cubans are no accident - and from
the Base Commander to the Lance
Corporal, every effort is made to avoid miscommunication and
misunderstanding - on an hourly basis.
Also under the JTF Marines assist in giving
press tours. They introduce visitors to places with historical significance,
such as the North East gate, where once Marines and Cuban military personnel
had quite lively non-combat interactions.
Marines also join the JTF in managing base logistics; making sure that the bases' geographical isolation doesn't interfere with
getting food on the table, so to speak. Just receiving perishable items in a
timely manner may be a bigger job than onlookers might realize. Were the
massive salad bars at the several chow halls not so attractive, the press
would surely note it.
Corps Stories happily reports that Marines there seem
well-adjusted and as hard-working as ever.
Yet in wanting to speak to these Marines, from Colonels to
Corporals, Corps Stories was operating way out of the planned press
itinerary. At every turn, the PAO staff accommodated - noteworthy
and also worthy of a letter to SouthCom's Commander, which he received.
Possibly our readers have visited the
National Parks of the Gettysburg or Bull Run battlefields. Once there, many,
many visitors have a rather supernatural experience: they sense in
subjective terms, the chilling events of thousands of lives lost, mournful
wounding and tortuous battle. This is mentioned as precursor to very
unexpected experience this journalist had at GTMO.
The Caribbean climate is completely disarming, especially to
a mid-Atlantic resident visiting in January. But approaching the gate at
Camp Delta, nearly 24 hours after a pleasant arrival, a shocking anger arose
in me. Despite the balmy breezes, the professional conversations and
activities, suddenly, I felt a presence not unlike I had felt visiting
Gettysburg. That I was now just yards away from people who would and may
kill my Marines in an instant. The presence of people who adore the
destruction of September 11. The presence of people that our very young
Constitution-defenders, must treat well despite the likelihood that they are
cowardly, un-uniformed murderers.
As I rode in the press bus, I was very surprised at this
emotion coming seemingly from nowhere. I used prayer quickly to restrain my
thoughts and to grasp the reality of whom I was in the presence of.
Marines killed from three years earlier rolled steadily
through my mind. Beaupre. Aubin. Kennedy...
The next day we went inside the
Camp, visiting the Administrative Review Board building and staff. When
leaving, as I wanted to interview another Marine, the PAO split us up, me
going with 1stSgt. Sheila Tunney, and the rest with other PAO staff. Their
bus delayed our exit through the sally port momentarily. As we sat there, an
open-cover Jeep pulled up and stopped just feet in front of 1stSgt. Tunney's
truck. In it were three Sailors, two facing forward, one facing back. Aside
the rear-facing Sailor was a detainee. He looked at me, and I at him for
what seemed like entirely too long. I will never forget the look in his
eyes. The arrogance of his countenance, the slight grin on his mouth, the
ambition in his eyes, it was enraging. I knew I was safe, but I realized
then one thing.
The three-hundred-odd detainees, screened out of nearly
74,000 first captured, are not our friends no matter how liberal a mind
Reporters will continue to visit and pace and wait patiently
for their moment, their story of witnessing something they imagine occurs at
Possibly the story of who really suffers at GTMO, those
peacefully handing some of the most dangerous on this planet, is right in
front of them.